haha exactly it's not about 'Phoenix gets an all-star'- that's irrelevant. A trade is supposed to decrease weaknesses and add strengths. Carter doesnt give them anything they need, whilst taking away things they DO need. Not hard to comprehend. It also isn't good asset management because Carter is nigh-on untradable.
ok lits break this trade down, PHX give away marion and barbosa and get in return TWO YOUNG and good centers who cn actually play D unlike every other post player they have.... and they get the player who can complement the scoring loss by barbosa and marion!! and they get another 3pt shooter and a good energy guy who ALSO can play D (yes sir, sasha can play D, im not being biased or something.. the guy is very active on that end and will always try to harass u and make ur shots more difficult)...
barbosa cant play D, so if u trade barbosa for VC ur ONLY GETTING AN UPGRADE, and when u trade marion for TWO YOUNG BIG MEN WHO CAN PLAY D (and krstic can really score) and a combo guard who can play the 1 2 3 and shoot from deep, this is at least on par...
this trade adds depth to the suns and makes them better on D and doesnt hurt their scoring!
i just cant see ur point, marion is their biggest headache and the "big 3" will be broken when they fail to reach the WCF this year so why not try something else??