B,A,C,D
B is first his completion percentage isn't far off from A and he throws more TD's. A has the better completion percentage but his numbers arent anymore efficient. Seems like a somewhat conservative QB. B throws more picks, but his TD/INT ratio isn't far off from A's. B needs to run the ball more, his YPC indicates he can run as well as pass.
C is the best runner of the group so he's third. Judging by his completion percentage and TD's he's certainly not a pocket that most likely struggles with accuracy down the field. D is too small of a sample size, and his Completion percentage is Josh Freeman esque.
Thanks!
You don't have enough information to rank them.
I know we don't have much info.
They are actually the 4 QBs who played for Montreal this season in the CFL.
A is Anthony Calvillo, who's the best QB in the history of the CFL, but he's now 41.
B is Josh Neiswander, a 2nd year CFL QB.
C is Tanner Marsh, a rookie QB who played for Arkansas Tech.
D is Troy Smith, who won the Heisman trophy with Ohio State in 2007 I think.
They all played, all had up and downs. Now Calvillo is out for the year, the other 3 are healthy and the Alouettes don't really know who they'll go with for the last 2 weeks of the season and in the playoffs.